Wednesday, November 12, 2014

Greatest College Basketball Programs of All Time, Updating Street & Smith's

In January 2005, Street & Smith's issued a 161-page publication entitled Greatest Basketball Programs of All Time.  They looked at over 300 Division I men's basketball programs and ranked them according to their historical success by applying a point system to several criteria.

The criteria and points awarded for each;

  • NCAA Championships - 25 points
  • NCAA Tournament Finals - 16 points
  • NCAA Final Fours - 14 points
  • NCAA Tournament Wins - 4 points
  • NCAA Tournament Appearances - 10 points
  • NIT Tournament Championships - 10 points
  • Conference Regular Season Championships - 12 points (points are split among ties)
  • Conference Tournament Championships - 6 points
  • Independent Championships - 6 points
  • All-Time Win-Loss Percentage - % x 40
  • Graduation Rate - 4-class average x 10
  • NCAA Major Infractions - subtract 3 points
  • First Round NBA Draft Picks - 1 point
There was also a whimsical category called Mascot Ferocity in which each program was awarded between minus-five to plus-five points based on its mascot.

Ten seasons have passed since that ranking, a significant amount of time to consider updating the rankings.  The table below updates the rankings through the 2013-14 season.

TOTAL POINTSNCAA Tourny App. X 10NCAA Tourny Wins x 4NCAA Final Fours x 14NCAA Tourny Finals x 16NCAA Championships x 25NIT Tourny Titles x 10Conference Champs x 12Conf. Tourny Champs x 6Independent Champs x 6All-Time Win-Loss % x 40Graduation Rate x 10NCAA Major Infractions x -31st Round Draft Picks x 1Official School MascotMascot Ferocity x 12004 RankingRanking ChangeNCAA Only Points
1Kentucky2347.265311616128239.832800.760.89439Wildcats51-1610
2North Carolina2022.36451101895131.082500.740.88146Tar Heels-3311411
3UCLA1991.604497171211130.00400.690.60335Bruins52-11533
4Kansas1954.8443961493049.171300.721.00531Jayhawks34-1229
5Duke1708.00389915104020.502400.701.00135Blue Devils25-1246
6Louisville1345.2440721033119.671700.660.58322Cardinals17+1951
7Indiana1211.803764865116.00000.640.42123Hoosiers16-1959
8UConn1139.303156544122.75700.640.17119Huskies39+1768
9Ohio State972.7426481051216.17400.610.53321Buckeyes-412+3697
10Arizona947.202951421022.00400.650.82219Wildcats514+4607
11Cincinnati918.942843632016.371000.630.43512Bearcats210-1634
12Syracuse909.02376153105.91510.690.45121Orange-515+3757
13Arkansas905.022940621019.41700.640.55211Razorbacks38-5591
14Michigan State902.30285983208.50400.600.73118Spartans425+11726
15Utah884.402735421123.25500.640.88210Utes411-4523
16Oklahoma State853.762638632016.33400.590.22010Cowboys413-3594
17Georgetown798.76294654106.83700.620.70013Hoyas-321+4633
18Texas789.243135300118.67200.631.00014Longhorns223+5492
19Temple772.203133200213.501020.650.82010Owls420-470
20NC State771.762335322011.331700.620.80415Wolfpack417-3494
21Pennsylvania765.062313100036.33000.630.8903Quakers-416-5296
22Michigan753.722144541210.41100.580.86124Wolverines526+4545
23Illinois744.843040510011.92200.650.78315Fighting Illini427+4546
24Villanova740.64334631115.17310.641.00110Wildcats532+8597
25Kansas State727.062833410015.83200.590.7518Wildcats522-3484
26Oklahoma712.062835420010.83700.610.7737Sooners224-2508
27Princeton699.762413100128.33000.621.0004Tigers519-8306
28West Virginia686.702525210213.501300.620.8936Mountaineers234+6394
29UNLV686.602033411011.751110.710.82314Running Rebels328-1429
30Western Ky680.502215000021.251900.670.8737Hilltoppers-231+1280
31Purdue669.542534210115.67100.630.7327Boilermakers230-1430
32Marquette665.86314132111.83120.620.7107Golden Eagles433+1573
33St. John's (NY)664.302727210511.00300.650.83216Red Storm-218-15422
34BYU641.962815000218.58300.620.8204Cougars436+2340
35Florida615.36173953204.83400.560.80211Gators496+61494
36Xavier585.422421000113.16900.590.8905Muscateers248+12324
37Maryland580.56233721114.33400.591.00219Terrapins135-2447
38Missouri578.462519000013.33800.600.75214Tigers5380326
39San Francisco578.401621322114.00100.580.4249Dons229-10368
40Wisconsin578.362029311011.58200.560.4037Badgers455+15399
41Memphis570.002020110112.201010.630.64413Tigers561+20310
42Gonzaga558.301719000016.501300.580.9115Bulldogs289+47246
43Notre Dame554.00333110000.50040.651.00119Fighting Irish439-4468
44California543.401720321112.50000.570.4628Golden Bears541-3349
45Houston527.10192652004.50510.590.25011Cougars437-8396
46Creighton526.601912000014.801200.600.9003Blue Jays345-1238
47Murray State519.10153000020.001500.640.8510Racers-452+5162
48Iowa516.56232731005.58200.591.0019Hawkeyes240-8396
49Stanford516.101723211210.00100.570.83013Cardinal-544-5331
50Pittsburgh510.56252410007.58400.590.5015Panthers560+10360
51Saint Joseph's490.001915000014.00500.600.9005Hawks443-8250
52LSU484.80202440007.25100.570.50213Tigers550-2352
53Weber State476.06156000017.83900.640.8521Wildcats551-2174
54Wyoming471.40149111015.85200.570.6405Cowboys442-12231
55Butler470.161219220011.33700.581.0001Bulldogs2100+45256
56UTEP459.44171411109.17520.570.4623Miners249-7281
57Wake Forest459.40222810013.25500.560.80213Deamon Deacons-346-11346
58Davidson438.40128000014.651200.541.0002Wildcats580+22152
59Miami of Ohio435.10176000015.50400.540.7512Redhawks347-12194
60Virginia433.56182420024.83200.560.8208Cavaliers156-4304
61Alabama429.50191800007.25700.620.87214Crimson Tide-354-7262
62Tennessee428.32201900007.41400.610.7018Volunteers377+15276
63Colorado421.601310200114.00100.520.7807Buffaloes465+2198
64Utah State418.6420600009.17800.591.0001Aggies282+18224
65Washington417.60161810009.50300.610.82210Huskies385+20246
66La Salle411.30121422115.00800.590.7718Explorers-453-13261
67New Mexico St404.0618710009.58800.570.1332Aggies270+3222
68Georgia Tech394.76162321002.33400.530.46119Yellow Jackets564-4296
69VCU372.66131210007.83800.650.8702Rams2NRN/A192
70Tulsa371.00151200026.50600.551.0004Golden Hurricane359-11198
71Holy Cross369.6012721115.7550.50.591.0004Crusadors368-3217
72Boston College368.36182200002.83220.560.7009Eagles474+2268
73DePaul365.80181520010.70070.610.60211Blue Demons257-16268
74New Mexico365.5615800009.08600.580.6418Lobos498+24182
75N. Carolina A&T360.60101000011.001600.570.3800Aggies262-13104
76Oregon State357.201310200010.00000.570.64112Beavers158-18198
77Iowa State355.40161610005.00300.500.6409Cyclones484+7238
78Southern Cal351.50151220006.50100.570.67111Trojans476-2226
79Bradley351.3081122046.50210.590.7747Braves563-16184
80Texas Tech343.00136000010.50500.551.0011Red Raiders367-13154
81Dayton340.64151711031.17210.591.0033Flyers379-2248
82Dartmouth337.40710220012.00000.461.0000Big Green-566-16170
83Ohio335.8013700009.25600.570.5002Bobcats186+3158
84Oregon332.90121511103.50300.540.73111Ducks194+10235
85Wichita State331.80111320017.50300.560.6445Shockers2NRN/A190
86Providence331.30161420020.00230.590.67010Friars-375-11244
87Pepperdine326.30135000011.00300.540.5702Waves-369-18150
88Chattanooga325.30103000011.00900.550.4311Moccasins381-7112
89Massachusetts325.2087000013.00500.530.5002Minutemen378-11108
90Idaho State318.16118000011.33200.500.6210Bengals573-17142
91Santa Clara314.20111110008.00200.581.0002Broncos372-19168
92SMU312.861010100010.33100.510.7524Mustangs371-21154
93Texas A&M306.6412900009.67200.520.5833Aggies2NRN/A156
94Florida State305.50141511002.00300.580.83410Seminoles4101+7230
95Arizona State304.16141300006.33000.530.8018Sun Devils292-3192
96Valparaiso301.8082000010.50900.520.9001Crusadors390-688
97Mississippi State292.00101110006.75400.550.5026Bulldogs299+2158
98Alcorn State291.4663000012.83600.550.5510Braves583-1572
99Rhode Island289.9086000012.00100.570.9102Rams2NRN/A104
100Montana287.6010200008.00900.540.5011Grizzlies5NRN/A108

New to the top 100; VCU, Wichita State, Texas A&M, Florida State, Rhode Island, Montana.
Dropped from the top 100; Navy, Charlotte, Seton Hall, Northeastern, Louisianna-Monroe, Loyola (Illinois).



Largest Gains in Rank, 2014 vs 2004*
2014 Rank2004 RankChange
Florida359661
Gonzaga428947
Butler5510045
New Mexico749824
Davidson588022
Memphis416120
Washington658520
Utah State648218
Wisconsin405515
*Virginia Commonwealth moved from unranked to 69th.



The Elite Eight

Often called the "Blue bloods", for many years six programs were considered elite, Kentucky, North Carolina, UCLA, Kansas, Duke and Indiana.  In recent years, Louisville and UConn have added to their resumes and should now be part of the discussion of elite programs.  The Street & Smith's formula shows a clear separation between these eight programs and the rest of the pack.  The graph below gives an interesting look at how these programs have been successful over time.


Accumulated Points Over Time





The Greatest Coaches
It's no surprise that applying the Street & Smith's formula to coaching careers shows that the best programs have been led by the best coaches.  Duke's Mike Kryzyzewski has made it to the top of the list and is still looking to add more achievements as he enters his 40th season.

SeasonsNCAA Tourny App. X 10NCAA Tourny Wins x 4NCAA Final Fours x 14NCAA Tourny Finals x 16NCAA Championships x 25NIT Tourny Titles x 10Conference Champs x 12Conf. Tourny Champs x 6Independent Champs x 6All-Time Win-Loss % x 40NCAA Major Infractions x -31st Round Draft Picks x 1TOTAL POINTS
1Mike Krzyzewski3930821184011.001300.760281278.40
2John Wooden291647121010015.50000.800111155.00
3Dean Smith3627651152114.001300.780241125.20
4Adolph Rupp412030654125.501300.82141011.80
5Roy Williams262463742014.00600.79025964.60
6Jim Calhoun402249433111.251200.70118855.00
7Denny Crum302342622014.001100.70213833.00
8Bob Knight42284553319.50000.71014819.40
9Jim Boeheim38315343105.91510.75120804.92
10Lute Olson342746521011.33400.74016786.56
11Rick Pitino29195073205.581200.74012766.56



By The Numbers


Most NCAA Tournament AppearancesMost NCAA Tournament Wins
Kentucky53Kentucky116
North Carolina45North Carolina110
UCLA44Duke99
Kansas43UCLA97
Louisville40Kansas96
Duke38Louisville72
Indiana37Indiana64
Syracuse37Syracuse61
Villanova33Michigan State59
Notre Dame33UConn56
Most NCAA Final Four AppearancesMost NCAA Final Game Appearances
North Carolina18Kentucky12
UCLA17UCLA12
Kentucky16Duke10
Duke15Kansas9
Kansas14North Carolina9
Louisville10Indiana6
Ohio State10Ohio State5
Indiana8Georgetown4
Michigan State8Michigan4
UConn4
Most NCAA ChampionshipsMost Regular Season Conference Championships
UCLA11Kansas49.17
Kentucky8Kentucky39.83
Indiana5Pennsylvania36.33
North Carolina5North Carolina31.08
Duke4UCLA30.00
UConn4Princeton28.33
Kansas3Utah23.25
Louisville3UConn22.75
Arizona22.00
Western Kentucky21.25
Most Conference Tournament ChampionshipsBest All-Time Winning Percentage
Kentucky28Kentucky76%
North Carolina25North Carolina74%
Duke24Kansas72%
Western Kentucky19UNLV71%
Louisville17Duke70%
North Carolina State17Syracuse69%
North Carolina A&T16UCLA69%
Murray State15Western Kentucky67%
Louisville66%
Most NBA First-Round Draft PicksPoints from the NCAA Tournament
North Carolina46Kentucky1610
Kentucky39UCLA1533
Duke35North Carolina1411
UCLA35Duke1246
Kansas31Kansas1229
Michigan24Indiana959
Indiana23Louisville951
Louisville22UConn768
Syracuse21Syracuse757
Ohio State21Michigan State726

No comments:

Post a Comment